From our beginning as a Methodist congregation, we have blessed with a variety of pastors with a single goal: to grow in our faith and serve the local community and the world. Each had strengths and the occasional weakness, but all served with dedication to make the love of Christ known to all.
| Pastor | Years of Service |
| Rev. Henry Hice | 1900-1901 |
| Rev. W. G. Fletcher | 1901 |
| Rev. J. A. Howland | 1902-1903 |
| Rev. Howard Dutill | 1903-1905 |
| Rev. W. J. Carpenter | 1905-1909 |
| Rev. J. Edgar Wilson | 1909 |
| Rev. J. R. Cason | 1909-1911 |
| Rev. J. B. Mitchell | 1911-1915 |
| Rev. L. M. Broyles | 1915-1931 |
| Rev. M. H. Norton | 1921-1923 |
| Rev. Felix R. Hill, Jr. | 1923-1924 |
| Rev. John T. Myers | 1924-1926 |
| Rev. Walt Holcomb | 1926-1929 |
| Rev. L. M. Broyles | 1929-1931 |
| Rev. Homer Thompson | 1931-1935 |
| Rev. Felix R. Hill, Jr. | 1935-1937 |
| Rev. Carlock Hawk | 1937-1940 |
| Rev. Harry H. Waller | 1940-1945 |
| Rev. Richard Broyles | 1945-1947 |
| Rev. O. Alton Murphy | 1947-1951 |
| Rev. Laurie G. Ray | 1951-1962 |
| Rev. Harold E. Buell | 1962-1967 |
| Rev. Caxton Doggett | 1967-1969 |
| Rev. Kenneth G. Rogers | 1969-1973 |
| Rev. J. Lloyd Knox | 1973-1977 |
| Rev. William Pickett | 1977-1985 |
| Rev. Richard W. Rohrer | 1985-1900 |
| Rev. Bradford Dinsmore | 1990-1992 |
| Rev. James A. Harnish | 1992-2014 |
| Rev. Roger Scholtz | 2014-2015 |
| Rev. Magrey deVega | 2015-present |